Lists
- A.V. Club: Jesse Hassenger: Best Films of 2017
- Scott Feinberg: Top Ten Films of 2017
- Vulture: David Edelstein: 10 Best Movies of 2017
- A.V. Club: A.A. Dowd: Best Films of 2017
- BuzzFeed: Alison Willmore: 11 Best Movies of 2017
- A.V. Club: 20 Best Films of 2017
- Jordan Hoffman: Top Ten Films of 2017
- A.V. Club: Noel Murray: Best Films of 2017
- New York Times: A.O. Scott: 21 Best Movies of 2017
- Guardian: 50 Top Films of 2017
- Uproxx: 20 Best Movies of 2017
- Huffington Post: Matthew Jacobs: 27 Best Movies of 2017
- AP: Jake Coyle: Best Films of 2017
- A.V. Club: Mike D’Angelo: Best Films of 2017
- Lists Curated by Toronto Film Review: Sophy Romvari: Top Ten Films of 2017
- Los Angeles Times: Justin Chang: 32 Best Films of 2017
- Consequence: Top 25 Movies of 2017
- RogerEbert.com: Allison Shoemaker: Top Ten Films of 2017
- RogerEbert.com: Brian Tallerico: Top Ten Films of 2017
- RogerEbert.com: Ben Kenigsberg: Best Films of 2017
- Genevieve Koski: Top 15 Films of 2017
- Los Angeles Times: Mark Olsen: 20 Best Films of 2017
- Les Inrocks: Emily Barnett: Top 10 Films of 2017
- Little White Lies: 30 Best Films of 2017
- Culture Trip: Graham Fuller: 20 Best Movies of 2017
- Variety: Owen Gleiberman: 10 Best Films of 2017
- New York Times: Manohla Dargis: 40 Best Movies of 2017
- David Ehrlich: 25 Best Films of 2017
- RogerEbert.com: Christina Newland: Top Ten Films of 2017
- Hollywood Reporter: Todd McCarthy: 20 Best Films of 2017
- IndieWire Poll: Best Movies of 2017
- A.V. Club: Katie Rife: Best Films of 2017
- Village Voice Film Poll: Best Films of 2017
- Vulture: Emily Yoshida: 10 Best Movies of 2017
- AP: Lindsey Bahr: Best Films of 2017
- Keith Phipps: Top 16 Films of 2017
- Paste: 50 Best Movies of 2017
- RogerEbert.com: Jacob Oller: Ten Best Films of 2017
- Nashville Scene: The 2017 Jim Ridley Memorial Film Poll
- Christy Lemire: 10 Best Films of 2017
- John Rangel: Favorite Films of 2017
- Insider: 100 Best Films of the 2010s
- A.V. Club: The 100 Best Movies of the 2010s
- Boston Globe: Ty Burr: The 50 Best Movies of the Decade
- RogerEbert.com: Sheila O’Malley: Best Films of 2017
- IndieWire: Eric Kohn: 17 Best Movies of 2017
- ScreenCrush: Matt Singer: 20 Best Films of 2017
- Artforum: J Hoberman: 10 Best Films of 2017
- RogerEbert.com: Ten Best Films of 2017
- Vox: Alissa Wilkinson: 35 Best Films of 2017
- Atlantic: Christopher Orr: Best Movies of 2017
- The Ringer: K. Austin Collins: 24 Best Movies of 2017
- Film Stage: Top 50 Films of 2017
- Daily: David Hudson: Top Ten Films of 2017
- Nictate: Top 10 Films of 2017
- Justine Smith: 30 Favorite Films of 2017
- IndieWire: Anne Thompson: 12 Best Films of 2017
- Ed Gonzalez: Top 30 Movies of 2017
- Chicago Tribune: Michael Phillips: 10 Best Movies of 2017
- Sight & Sound Poll: Top 26 Films of 2017
- Charles Bramesco: 25 Best Films of 2017
- Alicia Malone: Top 50 Films of 2017
- Chicago Reader: Ben Sachs: Favorite Films of 2017
- Film Comment Poll: 20 Best Films of 2017
- Village Voice: Bilge Ebiri: Best Movies of 2017
- A.V. Club: Ignatiy Vishnevetsky: Best Films of 2017
- Time Out New York: Joshua Rothkopf: 20 Best Films of 2017
- Slant: 50 Best Films of 2017
- Film School Rejects: Best Movies of 2017
- Paste: The 100 Best Movies of the 2010s
- Film School Rejects: The 100 Best Movies of the 2010s
- World of Reel: Jordan Ruimy: The 25 Best Movies of the 2010s
- Keith Phipps: Top 30 Films of the Decade
- The Playlist: The 100 Best Films of the Decade
- Guardian: Mark Kermode: Top 10 Films of 2017
- Vogue: John Powers: 10 Best Movies of 2017
- AP: Best 10 Films of the 2010s
- RogerEbert.com: Matt Zoller Seitz: Best Films of 2017
- Ryland Walker Knight: Favorite Feature Films of 2017
- GCN: Steve Erickson: Top 26 Films of 2017
- Lists Curated by Toronto Film Review: Lydia Ogwang: Top Ten Films of 2017
- RogerEbert.com: The Best Films of the 2010s
- Nellie Killian: Favorite Films of 2017
- Slate: Dana Stevens: Top 15 Movies of 2017
- Glenn Kenny: 63 Best Films of 2017
- Jeffrey M. Anderson: Top Ten Films of 2017
- Wall Street Journal: Joe Morgenstern: 10 Best Films of 2017
- Time: Stephanie Zacharek: Top 10 Movies of 2017
- Variety: Peter Debruge: 10 Best Films of 2017
- Pop Culture Happy Hour: Favorite Movies of 2017