Matt Bettinelli-Olpin and Tyler Gillett - Year-End Lists

Abigail
- #6 Best Films of 2024: Kim Newman: Sight & Sound: Sight & Sound Poll
- #9 Best Films of 2024: Katherine McLaughlin: Sight & Sound: Sight & Sound Poll
- Best Films of 2024: Jessica Green: Film Comment: Film Comment Poll
Scream VI
- #9 Best Films of 2023: Tara Judah: Sight & Sound: Sight & Sound Poll
- #82 Best Movies of 2023: Sean Fennessey
Scream
- #58 My Favorite Movies of 2022: Sean Fennessey
- Top Ten Films of 2022: Rendy Jones: RogerEbert.com Runner-up
Ready or Not
- #7 Top 10 Films of 2019: Kristen Lopez: RogerEbert.com
- Best Films of 2019: Kim Newman: Sight & Sound: Sight & Sound Poll
- Favorite Films of 2019: Max Weiss: Baltimore Magazine Honorable mention