Wilco
-
Ode to Joy
- Craig Jenkins: The Best Albums of 2019
- Uncut: 75 Best Albums of 2019
- Thrillist: The Best Albums of 2019
- Rolling Stone: The 50 Best Albums of 2019
- Uproxx Music Critics Poll: Best Albums of 2019
- Mojo: 75 Best Albums of 2019
- Rough Trade: Albums of the Year 2019
-
Schmilco
- Uncut: 75 Best Albums of 2016
- Consequence of Sound: Top 50 Albums of 2016
- Magnet: Top 25 Albums of 2016
- Paste: 50 Best Albums of 2016
- Entertainment Weekly: 50 Best Albums of 2016
- Mojo: 50 Best Albums of 2016
- Rolling Stone: 50 Best Albums of 2016
- Pazz & Jop: Top 100 Albums of 2016
-
Star Wars
- Magnet: Top 25 Albums of 2015
- American Songwriter: Top 50 Albums of 2015
- Entertainment Weekly: 40 Best Albums of 2015
- Jim DeRogatis: 40 Favorite Albums of 2015
- Rolling Stone: 50 Best Albums of 2015
- A.V. Club: 15 Best Albums of 2015
- Uncut: 75 Best Albums of 2015
- Diffuser: 50 Best Albums of 2015
- Mojo: 50 Best Albums of 2015
- Under the Radar: Top 100 Albums of 2015
- Consequence of Sound: Top 50 Albums of 2015
- Paste: 50 Best Albums of 2015
- Q: Top 50 Albums Of 2015
- Pazz & Jop: Top 100 Albums of 2015
-
The Whole Love
- American Songwriter: Top 50 Albums of 2011
- Bob Boilen: 11 Favorite Albums of 2011
- Chris Riemenschneider: Top 10 Albums of 2011
- Austin Powell: Top 10 Albums of 2011
- A.V. Club: Best Music of 2011
- Thomas Conner: Top Albums of 2011
- Ology: Top 15 Indie/Alternative Albums of 2011
- Todd Martens: Top 15 Albums of 2011
- Paste: 50 Best Albums of 2011
- Stephen Thompson: 10 Favorite Albums of 2011
- Rolling Stone: 50 Best Albums of 2011
- Eric R. Danton: Top 20 Albums of 2011
- Jim DeRogatis: 40 Favorite Albums of 2011
- Sonic: Best Albums of 2011
- Magnet: Top 20 Albums of 2011
- Hot Press: Top 30 Albums of 2011
- Entertainment Weekly: 20 Best Albums of 2011
- Guitar World: Top 50 Albums of 2011
- Epitonic: Top 40 Albums of 2011
- Pazz & Jop: Top 100 Albums of 2011
- Clash: Top 40 Albums of 2011
- Pretty Much Amazing: 40 Best Albums of 2011
- PopMatters: 75 Best Albums of 2011
- Rise: Records of the Year 2011
- Exclaim: 30 Best Pop & Rock Albums of 2011
- Mojo: Best Albums of 2011
- Treble: Top 50 Albums of 2011
- FasterLouder: Best Albums of 2011
- Under the Radar: Top 80 Albums of 2011
- Stereogum: Top 50 Albums of 2011
- Drowned in Sound: Favourite Albums of 2011