Year-End Lists

Who Will Look After the Dogs?

16. 50 Best Albums of 2025: Exclaim
23. The 50 Best Albums of 2025: Consequence
24. The 25 Best Albums of 2025: The Ringer
91. The 100 Best Albums of 2025: Our Culture

The Unraveling of PUPTheBand

15. Top 50 Albums of 2022: Consequence
36. 50 Best Albums of 2022: Exclaim
52. 100 Favorite Albums of 2022: Hanif Abdurraqib

• The 60 Best Albums of 2022: Josh Terry

Morbid Stuff

11. The Best Albums of 2019: Flood
14. Top 50 Albums of 2019: Consequence
20. Top 50 Albums of 2019: Brooklyn Vegan
23. Favorite Albums of 2019: Steven Hyden: Uproxx
25. Top 25 Albums of 2019: Magnet
26. The 50 Best Albums of 2019: NME
28. Best Albums of 2019: Uproxx: Uproxx Music Critics Poll
31. The 50 Best Albums Of 2019: Stereogum
42. Top 50 Albums of 2019: Anthony Fantano: The Needle Drop
47. The 50 Best Albums of 2019: Paste
91. The 100 Best Albums of 2019: Vice: Noisey

• The Best Albums of 2019: Andrew Barker: Variety
• Top 25 Albums of 2019: American Songwriter

The Dream Is Over

16. 20 Best Albums of 2016: Uproxx
22. 50 Best Albums of 2016: Stereogum
31. 40 Favorite Albums Of 2016: Hanif Abdurraqib
53. The 101 Best Albums Of The 2010s: Spin
74. Top 100 Albums of 2016: Village Voice: Pazz & Jop
98. The 100 Best Albums Of The 2010s: Stereogum

Pup

37. Top 50 Albums of 2014: Consequence