American Vandal

- San Francisco Chronicle: 14 Best TV Shows of 2018
- Kelly Lawler: 25 Best TV Shows of 2018
- Brandon Katz: 10 Best TV Shows of 2017
- Maureen Ryan: 20 Best TV Shows of 2017
- IndieWire: 10 Best TV Shows of 2017
- Sonia Saraiya: 25 Best TV Shows of 2017
- Daily Beast: 20 Best TV Shows of 2017
- Decider: Best TV Shows of 2018
- Alan Sepinwall: 20 Best TV Shows of 2018
- Playlist: Best TV Shows of 2018
- Little White Lies: 25 Best TV Shows of 2018
- Alan Sepinwall: 20 Best TV Shows of 2017
- A.V. Club: 20 Best TV Shows of 2017
- A.V. Club: Best TV of 2018
- Tim Goodman: Best TV of 2017
- Complex: 30 Best TV Shows of 2018
- A.V. Club: The 100 Best TV Shows of the 2010s
- Paste: The 100 Best TV Shows of the 2010s
- Consequence of Sound: Top 100 TV Shows of the 2010s